Prior exposure to conflicting health information reduces people’s receptivity to messages about widely recommended health behaviors | University of Minnesota Skip to main content
Wordmark of the University of Minnesota Twin Cities
News and Events

Utility Menu

  • MyU
  • One Stop
  • Jobs

Common Search Terms

  • Housing
  • Libraries
  • Bookstore
  • Tuition Cost
  • Academic Calendar

News Section Menu

  • Topics
  • Story Archive
  • For Journalists
  • Events

Task List

  • MyU
  • One Stop
  • Jobs
  • COVID-19: Fall 2020
  • Topics
    • Agriculture & Environment
    • Architecture & Design
    • Arts & Humanities
    • Business & Management
    • Campus Affairs
    • COVID-19
    • Education
    • Health
    • Law & Policy
    • Science & Technology
    • Social Sciences
    • Sports & Recreation
  • Story Archive
  • For Journalists
  • Events

We’re committed to keeping students, staff, and faculty safe.
Find updates on operations and resources.

COVID-19 Response Safe Campus

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. News & Events
  3. Prior exposure to conflicting health information reduces people’s receptivity to messages about widely recommended health behaviors
Research Brief

Prior exposure to conflicting health information reduces people’s receptivity to messages about widely recommended health behaviors

September 22, 2021
Woman drinking coffee and reading newspaper

University of Minnesota researchers are finding that prior exposure to conflicting health information reduces receptivity to messages about widely-recommended health behaviors.

Today’s public information environment is characterized by conflicting information about a wide range of health topics, including nutrition, cancer screening, e-cigarettes and, most recently, COVID-19. Research has shown exposure to conflicting information can negatively affect public understanding and trust in health recommendations. 

What is not known is whether such exposure might make people less receptive to other health messages, including those about widely recommended health behaviors for which there is little conflict, such as fruit and vegetable consumption and physical activity. The possibility of such “carryover effects” from exposure to conflicting information was recently tested by an interdisciplinary team of University of Minnesota researchers.

Published in the journal Annals of Behavioral Medicine, the U of M study involved a three-wave, online survey experiment with a representative sample of nearly 3,000 U.S. adults during the summer of 2020. Participants were randomly assigned to view a series of health news stories and social media posts about six different health topics including mammography screening and carbohydrate consumption. These stories and posts, which were shown to participants twice over a month-long period, differed only in whether they featured conflict over scientific evidence or guidance. At least one week after their second viewing, participants were asked to evaluate ads from several recent health campaigns about behaviors for which there is broad scientific consensus: fruit and vegetable consumption, physical activity, and colorectal cancer screening. 

Results showed that prior exposure to conflicting health information rendered people less receptive to messages about these widely recommended health behaviors.

  • Those who were previously exposed to conflict reported greater resistance to the health campaign ads, as well as lower perceptions of the health behaviors featured in those ads.
  • Statistical analysis indicated that carryover effects largely operated through people’s feelings of backlash toward health recommendations and research in general, which was elicited by their prior exposure to conflict. 

“These results are worrisome, particularly given a COVID-19 information landscape that is increasingly fraught with seemingly conflicting science, as our team’s past research has shown,” said Rebekah Nagler, study lead and an associate professor in the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication, and a Masonic Cancer Center member. “Ultimately, people’s cumulative, routine exposure to conflicting information about COVID-19 and other health issues could threaten the success of media campaigns and other public health messaging strategies—strategies that we as a country invest in heavily year after year to prevent cancer and other chronic diseases.”

Nagler and her colleagues are now thinking about how to intervene and interrupt the carryover phenomenon and better communicate with the public about evolving science.

This research was supported by a grant from the National Cancer Institute. 

  • Categories:
  • Health
  • Social Sciences
  • Research
Share this story
  • Link to share current story on Twitter
  • Link to share current story on Facebook
  • Link to share current story via email

More stories in Health

Drs. Beth Thielen and Kaz Nelson
Expert Alert

Living with COVID-19 in 2022

Drs. Beth Thielen and Kaz Nelson can speak about staying safe as COVID-19 stretches into the future.

Portrait of Professor Sarah Gollust
News Release

Rapid Response Media Messaging Research Will Promote Health and Racial Equity

Citing the urgent need for more effective and equitable health communication, researchers at the University of Minnesota (UMN) School of Public Health (SPH) and Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication (HSJMC) are collaborating with two other universities on a unique rapid response research endeavor funded with a newly announced $5 million grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF).

Editor's picks

A researcher studying tree logs to identify mountain pine beetles
Feature

Expecting the mountain pine beetle

U of M researchers are anticipating and preparing for the arrival of a top threat to Minnesota’s trees.

Heather Dodds instructs high school students in a classroom
Feature

Building pathways from high school to college

The U of M College in the Schools program helps high school students get ready for college.

Rex Bernardo, Hannah Stoll, Michael Burns, and Chidi Chidozie crouch in a field near African vegetables.
Feature

Bringing a taste of home much closer

A new Vegetable Working Group aims to fill the food void in native African vegetables for local immigrants.

Four differently colored versions of a man in a baseball cap and sweater, ranging from photo to gray virtual representation.
Feature

Making computers smarter—with TikTok dance videos

A grad student uses frame-by-frame data to construct more realistic 3D avatars of real people.

See all stories
UMN Crookston UMN Morris UMN Duluth UMN Twin Cities UMN Rochester

System Campuses

  • System Website
  • Crookston
  • Duluth
  • Morris
  • Rochester
  • Twin Cities

For Journalists

  • Find an Expert
  • For Journalists
  • Guidelines for Journalists
  • Meet the PR Team

Contact

[email protected] 612-624-5551
Do you know what
the University of Minnesota
University of Minnesota
does for you?
Driven to Discover Campaign

Connect with us

  • Link to U of M's Facebook page
  • Link to U of M's Instagram page
  • Link to U of M's LinkedIn page
  • Link to U of M's Twitter page
  • Link to U of M's Youtube page
Wordmark of the University of Minnesota Twin Cities
  • Crookston
  • Duluth
  • Morris
  • Rochester
  • Twin Cities
© Regents of the University of Minnesota. All rights reserved.
The University of Minnesota is an equal opportunity educator and employer.
Privacy Statement | Report Web Disability-Related Issue
Website Feedback